By Andrew-Ryan Profaci, former Father God of Love Has Won. Featured in HBO’s Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God (2023), Dateline NBC, VICE, Rolling Stone, TIME, The New York Times, CNN, People, and Variety.
Public sources name four Father Gods of Love Has Won. I’m one of them — the only one she ever left the cult for, the one who later struggled to watch her body wrapped in Christmas lights from across the country. And four is a fraction of how many she actually had.
The cult had at least thirteen. My current count is thirteen I can document by name and tenure, with two to five more likely in a 2017-2019 window I’m still verifying. Most have never been named anywhere: not the HBO documentary, not Wikipedia, not in any of the major news features written about the cult.
Father God was a coveted position inside Love Has Won. It was the doctrine’s most sacred role for a man — the twin flame, the divine masculine counterpart to Mother God, the man Amy “recognized” as her cosmic match. Men joined the group hoping to be the one. Some came across the world. Some sold their savings for the chance. The position carried real power inside the cult’s structure: presence in livestreams, access to Amy’s inner circle, the title that the entire belief system was organized around. And yet, across fourteen years, at least thirteen men held it. None of them stayed. Most got demonized on the way out.
I can write this article for one specific reason. Of every man Amy Carlson called Father God, I’m the only one she left the cult for. After I left in August 2015, Amy walked out of the group to be with me — for approximately six to eight weeks before the gravity of the cult, and “Archangel Michael,” pulled her back. Before that, I’d built and run the cult’s entire digital body: the websites, the content, the audience. The cult I joined was a small Galactic Free Press splinter; The First Contact Ground Crew Team. And the group I left as Father God was 5DNews and 5DSpiritualHealing — the brand the world later came to know as “Love Has Won” only existed after I left, when they had to rebuild from nothing in the void I created. And during my time inside, Amy shared private material with me she never shared with anyone else.
This piece corrects the public record on two specific points.
First, the complete insider lineage — thirteen confirmed Father Gods, in chronological order, with tenure and context for each. Second, the pattern underneath the lineage. The cycle that produced thirteen Father Gods wasn’t random. It was load-bearing architecture from the very first transition, and it explains nearly everything else about how Love Has Won actually worked.
Key Findings
- The Love Has Won cult had at least thirteen Father Gods over fourteen years, not the four publicly documented in HBO, Wikipedia, and major news coverage.
- Andrew-Ryan Profaci was the only Father God Amy Carlson ever left the cult for. After his departure in August 2015, Amy followed him out for approximately six to eight weeks before returning. He also built and ran the cult’s entire digital infrastructure during his tenure — and when he left, he took it with him.
- The cult nearly collapsed during Amy’s absence in late 2015. Of the membership from that era, only two stayed loyal. Love Has Won was rebuilt from near-zero starting in late 2015 — and everyone, other than Miguel Lamboy, aka “Archangel Michael,” publicly associated with the HBO-era cult joined after this rebuild.
- Amy assigned demon names to departed Father Gods calibrated to how much epistemic access each had to her actual decision-making moments. Amerith became Aleister Crowley. Orion became Beelzebub. Andrew-Ryan Profaci became Lucifer the Lightbringer — the heaviest assignment in the lineage.
- Jason Castillo was the only Father God to remain in the role until Amy’s death in April 2021. Every other Father God was eventually displaced.
What “Father God” Meant Inside Love Has Won
To understand the lineage, you have to understand what “Father God” meant inside the group.
Amy Carlson was Mother God. That was the central claim — not metaphor, not aspirational language, but a literal cosmic identity she and her followers treated as established fact. She was the divine feminine incarnate, returned to Earth to anchor “5D ascension” for humanity. The full theology was a mix of channeled New Age cosmology, Hollow Earth folklore, ascended-master mythology, and twin flame doctrine — sourced loosely from Galactic Free Press writing in the early years, then reshaped under her authority into the doctrine that, in 2015, would eventually crystallize under the brand name “Love Has Won.”
The Father God role flowed directly from Mother God’s status. If Amy was the divine feminine, she needed a divine masculine counterpart — what twin flame theology calls the matched soul, the other half of a single being split across two bodies. The Father God was that counterpart. In Amy’s framing, he wasn’t appointed and he wasn’t elected. He was recognized. She would meet someone, declare a connection, and within days or weeks announce to the group that her Father God had arrived.
Two things about that framing matter for the lineage that follows.
First, the doctrine of recognition was inherently unstable. If Father God was someone Amy recognized, then Father God could also be someone she stopped recognizing — without contradiction, without theological crisis. The role was structurally mobile from the start.
Second, there was always a built-in explanation for transitions. When a Father God’s tenure ended — for any reason — Amy and the group had a phrase ready: “He couldn’t hold the energy.” The current Father God’s failure was framed as spiritual inadequacy, not as Amy’s compulsion or the role’s instability. The new Father God’s arrival was framed as divine timing — usually with a story about how he’d been “sent” or “called” to find her.
That doctrine of recognition, combined with the “couldn’t hold the energy” exit framing, is what made thirteen Father Gods possible across a single fourteen-year arc.
For broader context on the cult itself, see the Love Has Won entry on Wikipedia.
The Thirteen Father Gods
(In Order)
What follows is the chronological lineage. Thirteen men held the title, plus two additional figures who occupied the role’s edge — one who carried some of the energy without ever fully being installed, and one who was promised the title before Amy reversed her choice. Where I use pseudonyms or first names only, I’m honoring privacy decisions for men who haven’t publicly named themselves.
Quick-reference timeline:
| # | Father God | Tenure | One-Line Identifier |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amerith WhiteEagle (Robert Saltsgaver) | ~2012 to 2014 | The first Father God; helped Amy come to believe she was Mother God |
| — | Will (transitional) | ~2014 (brief) | Carried some Father God energies between Amerith and Miguel; never installed |
| 2 | Miguel Lamboy (Archangel Michael Silver) | A few weeks in 2014 | Stepped back to permanent archangel role; reported Amy’s body to police in 2021 |
| 3 | Peter Koyote (“Grandpaw”) | 2014 | Not related to the actor; between Miguel and Orion |
| 4 | Orion | Mid-2014 to October 2014 | Hopi-resonant; left after foot-stomping incident with Miguel |
| 5 | Krishna | One night, late 2014 | Young Indonesian-Indian member; 48 hours before Andrew’s arrival |
| 6 | Andrew-Ryan Profaci | November 2014 to August 2015 | Built the brand; the only Father God Amy left the cult for |
| — | Slowy / Archangel Uriel (promised, reversed) | June 2015 | Brought from France expecting to be installed; Amy reversed |
| 7 | “Greg” | June to December 2015 | Paid approximately $500,000 to the group; exited broke; now deceased |
| 8 | Florida Beach Father God | Late 2015 | Beach ceremony video (later scrubbed); attacked Andrew on video |
| 9 | Richard the Door Guy | January 2016 | Appeared at Andrew’s door with a Spanish woman; bracelet evidence preserved |
| 10 | Unidentified Father God | Late January 2016 | Visible in some videos with Amy; otherwise undocumented in any source |
| 11 | John Robertson (later “Father of Multiverse”) | ~2017 to August 2018 | Demoted to FM consolation title and stayed in group; arrested 2021 |
| 12 | Jason Castillo | August 2018 to April 2021 | The final Father God; only one to remain in role until Amy’s death |
Plus an estimated two to five additional Father Gods likely existed inside 2016-2019 window currently being verified through local video archive review.
The long-form lineage follows.
Amerith WhiteEagle (Robert Saltsgaver) — ~2012 to 2014
Amerith held the Father God role from approximately 2012 through 2014 — a roughly two-year tenure during the formative years when Love Has Won was still operating under the Galactic Free Press banner. He and Amy had connected several years earlier on the Lightworkers.org forum (around 2007), but the Father God installation came later. During those years as Father God, Amerith helped Amy come to believe she was Mother God — that her self-deification wasn’t just spiritual but literal. The dynamic in that era was foundational: not the cyclic displacement that would define the years after, but a slow co-creation of what the group would eventually become.
The end came around 2014, when Amerith tried to put a check on Amy’s self-deification. He attempted to question her belief that she was the God — the one and only — and that challenge was the structural trigger for his demonization. Amy reframed him to new group members as the reincarnation of Aleister Crowley, the dark masculine occultist who, in her telling, had been trying to thwart Mother God’s plans to bring about a “Golden Age” for humanity. The specific demon assignment is worth noting: Crowley was a figure who in his real-life work devoted himself to channeled supernatural systems. Naming Amerith as Crowley was Amy’s way of saying that the man who’d helped her build her doctrine had been corrupted by the same work he’d helped her build.
Between Amerith and Miguel — Will (Transitional)
Between Amerith’s exit and Miguel’s brief tenure, a senior team member known publicly under his given name (Will) carried some Father God energies without ever fully holding the title. Amy’s framing at the time wasn’t a full installation — she said he “carried some of the energy” — and the role transitioned to Miguel without a formal public installation between them. After Will departed, he received his own demon name in Amy’s framework: Loki, the trickster. The assignment was structurally apt. He had occupied the role’s edge without ever fully committing, which in Amy’s reframing made him a figure who hovered at thresholds without true presence — the trickster who never quite was.
Miguel Lamboy (Archangel Michael Silver) — A Few Weeks in 2014
Miguel Lamboy took the Father God role for a matter of weeks after Will stepped back — somewhere between two and four weeks by his own later account. His arrival was the transition Amy would later mythologize as “Archangel Michael came to save her” — not a relationship update but a divine rescue narrative inserted into the cult’s emerging cosmology. Miguel himself, however, didn’t want the role. He’d later tell me directly: “It just wasn’t for me.” He stepped back into a permanent identity as Archangel Michael Silver — no longer the Father God, but Mother God’s chief archangel and most trusted operational lieutenant.
Miguel’s place in Love Has Won history is unique. After his brief Father God window, he handled the group’s official and legal filings, managed money, and operated as Amy’s enforcer and partner in everything except the cosmic-romantic role. He never left her side. He was present at her death in April 2021, but seemed wise enough to get in front of the issue. “Archangel Michael” was the one who went to the Saguache County Sherriff’s Office on April 28, 2021 to report Amy’s death and location. He was NOT one of the seven members arrested when authorities recovered her body from the Crestone home, and remains the only major figure in the group who never displaced or was displaced. The Father God title moved past him; he simply stepped sideways and stayed.
Why he suddenly broke from the cult’s belief system at the end — but not enough to get Amy real medical care while she was still alive — remains a mystery.
Peter Koyote (“Grandpaw”) — 2014
Between Miguel stepping back into his permanent archangel role and Orion’s arrival, Peter Koyote — known inside the group as “Grandpaw” — held the Father God role briefly in 2014. He is not related to the actor Peter Coyote, whose name spelling is similar but who has no connection to Love Has Won or to any Father God in this lineage.
Peter’s tenure was short. Like several of the brief Father Gods, he is documented primarily through the recollections of ex-members who were present during his window, rather than through public-facing cult content. His existence was confirmed in May 2026 by multiple ex-members who came forward after the publication of this article — exactly the kind of structural-corroboration loop the article’s framing invited. As more details become verified, this entry will be updated.
What Peter Koyote’s presence here documents, even at the level of a few weeks, is that the 2014 stretch of the Father God cycle was running at a pace that the public record has never captured. Between Amerith stepping back, Will carrying transitional energies, Miguel’s installation and stepping back, Peter’s brief tenure, Orion’s arrival, Krishna’s single night, and my installation — that’s seven distinct Father God or near-Father-God configurations inside a single calendar year. The displacement cycle wasn’t slow when the cult was young. It was already running at the same compulsive pace that would define its entire fourteen-year arc.
Orion — Mid-2014 to October 2014
Orion — Mid-2014 to October 2014
Orion came next, taking the Father God role for two to three months from mid-2014 through October. He was about thirty, with long straight blond hair, dressed in white, and resonated deeply with Hopi spiritual tradition — collecting eagle feathers from the Colorado mountains around the group’s base and using them in prayer and meditation. He appeared on livestreams in the group’s chatroom daily during his tenure; the YouTube videos featuring him have since been deleted from the channel.
His exit was the cult’s first openly volatile Father God transition. According to accounts I received from both Miguel Lamboy and Amy herself, Orion had a falling out with Amy that ended with him “spinning out” in anger and stomping on Miguel’s foot before walking out of the cult. The version Amy told publicly was different: she made a video saying Orion had “gone to visit the Hopis for guidance.” He was never heard from again in or around the group.
For his demon assignment, Amy named Orion as Beelzebub — the Lord of the Flies, in some traditions the Devil himself. The intensity of the demonization is worth noting: a two-to-three-month Father God who left in anger received the heaviest possible demon name in the lineage. The variable wasn’t tenure length. It was the visibility of his rage. Beelzebub fit the man who had stomped on the archangel’s foot.
Krishna — One Night, Late 2014
Krishna held the Father God role for a single night. He was a young Indonesian-Indian man — not yet twenty, kind and curious by nature. Amy’s report afterward was that he had “held” Father God energies during their night together but had been unable to hold them longer. Her stated reason: he “wouldn’t let go.” His questioning, his refusal to fully surrender to the doctrine, his unwillingness to stop asking — these were what disqualified him from holding the role permanently. Amy said he “came very close” to becoming Father God for good.
The timing matters. Amy already knew at this point that I was on my way to join the team. Krishna’s one night happened approximately 48 hours before my arrival — a brief installation followed by a near-immediate transition. From outside it looks like coincidence. From inside, it reads as the cycle running at maximum velocity in anticipation of the next confirmed Father God. The doctrine of recognition was already preselecting.
Andrew-Ryan Profaci — November 2014 to August 2015
I arrived forty-eight hours after Krishna’s brief tenure ended. Amy installed me as Father God almost immediately. I stayed in the role for approximately nine months on the team. After I left in August 2015, Amy followed me out of the cult for another six to eight weeks. Counting both periods, my total involvement with Amy spanned roughly a year — from November 2014 to November 2015.
During my tenure as Father God, I built and ran the cult’s entire digital body. The group I joined had been through two prior brand identities — Galactic Free Press, then First Contact Ground Crew Team — and had a thin web presence built on Miguel-era technical scaffolding. I built out two new domains during my time as Father God: 5DNews.com as the content layer and 5DSpiritualHealing.com as the monetization layer. I also built and grew the 5DNews Facebook page to roughly 30,000 followers — the cult’s largest single audience asset at the time. The cult during my tenure operated under those properties. The name “Love Has Won” did not exist yet. It became the cult’s brand only after I left — when they had to rebuild from nothing, and named what grew in the void.
Other than Amerith and Jason Castillo, I was the only Father God between 2012 and 2020 to be regularly in the cult’s daily YouTube videos. Most Father Gods weren’t on camera with Amy. I appeared in dozens of near-daily videos across most of my tenure.
“I’m the only Father God Amy Carlson ever left the cult for.”
The story of how my tenure ended — and why my departure became the structural turning point in the entire cult’s history — is the next major section of this article. The short version: I uncovered a hoax inside the cult that forced Amy to choose between truth and the doctrine, and she chose the doctrine. After I left, she followed me out of the cult for six to eight weeks before returning to rebuild Love Has Won from near-zero. My demonic assignment was Lucifer the Lightbringer — the fallen light-bearer. The section after the lineage explains why that specific name.
Between Andrew and Greg — Slowy / Archangel Uriel (Promised, Reversed)
A young French man arrived in northern California in June 2015 — known first as Slowy, later as Archangel Uriel within the group. Amy had recruited him from France with the explicit promise that he would become Father God upon arrival, displacing me. (I had begun, by that point, to reject Amy’s teachings and her claim to be Mother God.) But when Slowy arrived with a friend to join the team, Amy had a change of heart. The installation didn’t happen. Slowy became a regular team member instead — and later called Amy out publicly for promising one thing and delivering another. He wanted the title he’d been promised.
“Greg” — June to December 2015
“Greg” arrived in June 2015 — shortly after Slowy — and eventually replaced me as Father God. He was approximately 55 when he joined the group, successful, financially stable, with a home and a 401k. Within months of joining, he had sold the home, liquidated the retirement account, and transferred roughly $500,000 to Love Has Won. He held the Father God title from sometime that summer through December 2015, when his tenure ended and he left the group broke. He has since passed away.
Greg’s case is the cleanest documented instance of the Consolation Infrastructure’s financial-settlement mechanism. His tenure as Father God overlapped with my own slow exit from the role and the cult — my growing rejection of Amy’s teachings created the opening Greg was used to fill. His financial extraction represents the cycle running through the prosperity-doctrine angle: a Father God who paid to be Father God, and who left the role broke. I’ve documented his case in detail in Mother God’s Ultimate Con: The Man Who Paid $500K to Be Father God →.
The Florida Beach Father God — Late 2015
After Greg’s exit in December 2015, the Father God role passed briefly to a man in his mid-to-late thirties, a Black member of the group whom Amy publicly recognized as Father God in a YouTube ceremony filmed on a Florida beach. That video has since been scrubbed from the group’s YouTube channel. His tenure overlapped with the period after I’d left and Amy had followed me out — meaning Amy was installing Father Gods publicly via livestream while not actually being in the group full-time. The installation served partly as theater intended to demonstrate continuity of leadership during her absence.
He made at least one video attacking me personally after my departure — calling me a demon, claiming that I had “stolen from love,” and predicting I would “pay the price for it.” That video is one of the surviving artifacts of the Lucifer demonization arc playing out in real time — public proof that Amy and the group were broadcasting the demon assignment to followers through the men who held the Father God title after me.
Richard the Door Guy — January 2016
In January 2016, a man calling himself Richard appeared at my door in Florida. He arrived with a Spanish woman in her late thirties or early forties, said the line “wow, you have really intense energy,” and claimed to be Father God of Love Has Won — though notably he also said he didn’t believe Amy was Mother God. He and his companion wanted me to return to the group. After he left, I found a bracelet and a hand-written address left for me in my mailbox; the image is preserved and available for this article. (See below.)
What followed was the formal beginning of Amy’s stalking arc. She made videos publicly directed at me — naming me Lucifer and demanding I “come back home into the light.” Richard’s role appears to have been as messenger: he was installed briefly as Father God for the purpose, in part, of legitimizing the public outreach to me. His tenure was brief and effectively performative. He doesn’t appear in any of the videos that survived on the group’s YouTube channel.
The Unidentified Father God of Late January 2016
After Richard’s brief tenure, late January 2016 brought another figure into the role — a different man visible in some videos with Amy from that period, but unnamed and unidentified in any public source. His tenure was short enough that he doesn’t appear in any later videos. Whether he was a full Father God in Amy’s own framing or briefly considered for the role, I can’t fully confirm. His existence is documented by the late-January 2016 videos and his absence from everything that came after.
John Robertson (later “Father of Multiverse”) — 2017 to August 2018
The next confirmed Father God after January 2016 was John Robertson — though his Father God tenure is most commonly remembered through the consolation title Amy invented for him: “Father of Multiverse,” or “FM.” Robertson was active in the role from sometime in 2017 through the summer of 2018, when Jason Castillo replaced him. He remained in the group as Father of Multiverse rather than leaving — the only instance in the entire lineage where a displaced Father God stayed inside the cult under a demoted title. He was one of the seven members later arrested in 2021 when authorities recovered Amy’s body from the Crestone home; his identity is confirmed via court records.
Robertson and Castillo can be seen having conflict in the HBO documentary — a residue of the prolonged transition between their tenures. The Father of Multiverse designation Amy invented for Robertson was a structural innovation: rather than displace him fully, she demoted him to a new role that allowed Castillo to take the Father God title while Robertson remained adjacent. It’s the cult’s clearest example of the demotion-with-title mechanism in the Consolation Infrastructure. After Amy’s death, Robertson would go on to co-found the splinter group Joy Rains with Castillo, carrying versions of the Love Has Won theology forward under new branding.
Jason Castillo — August 2018 to April 2021
Jason Castillo took the Father God role in August 2018 and held it until Amy’s death in April 2021 — approximately thirty-two months, the longest single Father God tenure in the lineage. His arrival included the longest documented courtship-to-installation window — approximately five months from his March 2018 meeting with Amy through the August 2018 installation, with Robertson active in the role throughout. Castillo is the Father God most widely known publicly because his tenure overlapped with the cult’s HBO-era visibility; he was on screen in the documentary, present at Amy’s death, and one of the seven members arrested when authorities recovered her body from the Crestone home. Because his story differs structurally from every other Father God in this lineage — he was the only one to remain in the role until Amy’s death rather than being displaced — the section after next is devoted to his tenure specifically.
The Pattern — How Amy’s Cycle Actually Worked
If you read those thirteen entries chronologically, you’ve just seen a single mechanism running on repeat for fourteen years.
It looked like spontaneous love stories from the inside. It looked, even to those of us inside it, like genuine recognition events — Amy finding her real Father God this time, the previous one having been an error or a betrayal. Each transition got a unique narrative, a unique reason it ended, a unique reason the next one had arrived. It felt, to each of us in turn, like the singular cosmic recognition the doctrine described.
It wasn’t. The same architecture ran thirteen times.
I watched it happen during my own time with her, and I heard her describe earlier transitions in language she didn’t realize gave the pattern away. The clearest example was how she narrated the first transition — Amerith to Miguel, around 2014. She didn’t say her relationship with Amerith had ended and Miguel had become her new partner. She said “Archangel Michael came to save her.”
That’s not a relationship update. That’s mythology. Miguel wasn’t her next man; he was a divine rescuer. Amerith wasn’t her previous partner; he was a dark force she’d been saved from. The narrative was instantly mythologized — the new man elevated to cosmic agent, the old man retroactively reframed as a danger, Amy positioned as the rescued rather than the displacer.
That same architecture ran through every Father God transition that came after. Three patterns are worth naming.
The Displacement Cycle
Amy didn’t choose Father Gods deliberately. She felt attraction, mythologized it as divine recognition, declared the man Father God, and then — eventually, sometimes within weeks — felt that attraction shift to someone else. As I’ve described it before: “She was always displacing the current Father God with a new one, usually just the next guy she was attracted to.” The doctrine of recognition gave the compulsion theological cover.
“The cycle didn’t break for fourteen years. It only ended when she died.”
The cycle’s velocity varied — sometimes years between transitions in the early era, sometimes weeks between transitions during the post-collapse rebuild. The fastest churn was in Florida in late 2015 through January 2016: four Father Gods in roughly four months. Greg through December, then the Florida Beach Father God, then Richard, then the unidentified figure of late January. That’s the cycle running at maximum compulsion frequency — and it correlates exactly with the period when Amy was most structurally unstable, having just been pulled back from the brink of life outside the cult. The more threatened she was, the faster the cycle ran.
The Consolation Infrastructure
A displaced Father God couldn’t simply disappear — the doctrine wouldn’t permit it. So Amy and the group developed three exit mechanisms, calibrated case by case.
The first was demotion with a new title. Miguel became Archangel Michael Silver permanently after his brief Father God window. Robertson became Father of Multiverse when Castillo arrived. The mechanism preserved the displaced man’s place inside the cosmology while clearing the Father God slot for the next installation.
The second was demonic reclassification. Amerith was reframed as the reincarnation of Aleister Crowley — the dark masculine occultist whose work paralleled the channeled-supernatural systems Amerith had helped Amy build. Will, who had carried some of the energy between Amerith and Miguel without ever fully holding the title, became Loki the trickster — the figure who hovers at thresholds without true presence. Orion, who left the cult in anger, was named Beelzebub — the Lord of the Flies, the figure of pure rage. And I, who left after exposing a hoax that forced Amy’s choice between truth and the doctrine, became Lucifer the Lightbringer — the fallen light-bearer.
The third was financial settlement. Greg exited broke after his nearly $500,000 had been transferred to the cult. The Consolation Infrastructure used cash where it couldn’t use mythology — when the displaced Father God hadn’t earned a place inside the cosmology through prior contribution, the mechanism that managed his exit was financial extraction or settlement.
Most cases used a combination.
The Exit-Management Protocol
The demonic reclassification was systematic, not situational. Every Father God who left was eventually revealed to have been a demon all along.
But it’s worth being precise about what the system was actually managing. The intensity of the demonization didn’t scale to tenure length, or to public visibility, or to how dramatically a man left. It scaled to one specific variable: how much epistemic access the departed Father God had to Amy’s actual decision-making moments.
Amerith had been present for the formative moment of Amy’s self-deification — the moment she came to recognize, with his help, that she was God. When he later tried to put a check on that claim, his demonization had to be heavy enough to disqualify his memory of that formative moment. Aleister Crowley was the name assigned because the demon had to match the depth of what Amerith knew.
I had been present for the moment Amy was given a clean choice between acknowledging a hoax she’d been victimized by and suppressing the truth to preserve the doctrine. She chose suppression. My demonization had to be the most thorough of all the Father Gods who ever left, because I was the one person on Earth who could verify that her doctrine wasn’t innocent error but conscious maintenance. Lucifer the Lightbringer fit the specific failure mode: the man who had brought the light to the cult — who had built and run its entire digital body — and then took the light with him when he left, leaving the cult to assemble a new identity in the dark. The man who saw the moment the light went dark from the inside, then took the light away.
Departures Amy could survive theologically — Miguel withdrawing into his archangel role, Robertson taking the FM consolation title — got mild demonization or none at all. Departures where the departed Father God didn’t hold deep epistemic access to Amy’s decision moments — the Florida Beach Father God, Richard, the late-January-2016 figure — got named as demons in passing but never as primary villains.
The pattern wasn’t every leaver becomes a demon. The pattern was every leaver who had seen something gets a demon name proportional to what they saw. As I’ve described it before: “Everyone who ever left the group became a demon in Amy’s eyes. It was her way of reducing their credibility and explaining why they would leave ‘God,’ without having to explain that they didn’t think she was God after getting to know her.” The structural reason that worked was that it pre-emptively destroyed the credibility of the only people who could refute Amy’s account of her own choices.
“The pattern wasn’t every leaver becomes a demon. The pattern was every leaver who had seen something gets a demon name proportional to what they saw.”
The “Always About to Happen” Doctrine
There’s one more pattern worth naming, not specifically about Father Gods but about the verbal architecture that made the Father God cycle possible.
With Amy, something was always about to happen. The Great Awakening. The 5D ascension. The galactic event that would prove everyone in the cult had been right about everything. None of it ever did happen. But Amy had to become an expert at explaining how something was happening but wasn’t — how the predicted event had technically taken place even though we were somehow still waiting for it. It was a verbal skill she had to develop, inevitably, because of the corners she’d backed herself into with all the predictive doctrine she’d proposed.
The same flexibility that explained away failed prophecies explained away Father God transitions. “He couldn’t hold the energy” was the same kind of verbal device as “the ascension already happened on another timeline” — both let the cult survive a contradiction that should have collapsed it. The doctrine of recognition was downstream of the same skill. A Father God who failed didn’t disprove the doctrine; he just hadn’t been able to manifest what the doctrine had already proven was true.
What this reveals is structural: the Father God cycle wasn’t just about Amy’s compulsion. It was supported by, and embedded in, a broader doctrinal machine that had been trained from the beginning to explain away failure. The cycle could run thirteen times because the doctrine had a fourteen-year habit of running on failed predictions and continuing anyway. Father Gods came and went; the cult continued. Prophecies failed and were retconned; the cult continued. The verbal flexibility was the load-bearing skill that kept the structure intact through everything that should have collapsed it.
A Final Pattern Worth Naming
The selection criteria for Father Gods changed over time. In the early and middle periods, intelligence was a consistent thread — Amy was drawn to men who could engage her doctrinally, philosophically, intellectually. The men capable of being in the conversations that gave her doctrine a complicated surface. By the final era — Robertson and Castillo — that criterion had dropped out. The selection had narrowed to attraction and emotional dependence, to men less likely to ask the questions that could collapse the doctrine.
The cycle didn’t just run thirteen times. The criteria for entering the cycle degraded. As the doctrine drifted further from anything verifiable, Amy’s Father God selection drifted accordingly — toward men less able to interrogate her, more reliant on her authority, less likely to walk away with intact knowledge of what they’d seen. The cult deteriorated; the Father Gods deteriorated with it.
When the Cult Almost Ended (And the Father God They Could Never Forgive)
The Love Has Won that HBO documented — the Crestone compound, the seven-person arrest, the Christmas-lights mummification, the late-era splinter groups — almost didn’t happen.
In 2014 and 2015, when I was Father God, the cult was a different organization. Mid-sized, based first in Colorado and then northern California, scaling steadily. I’d built and run the technical infrastructure — 5DNews.com, 5DSpiritualHealing.com, and the 30,000-follower 5DNews Facebook page — that put the group on the map and gave it a working digital body. The group had momentum. The doctrine seemed, from inside, to still be operating in good faith.
Roughly halfway through my tenure, the cult experienced what I would later document as the greatest hoax in its history — a manipulation involving fake supernatural beings, a senior team member, and a series of late-night “healing sessions” with Amy that were not what they were presented as.
The short version: a group of fake online entities calling themselves “Quantum Beings” appeared in our chatroom, performed apparent miracles, and gained legend status within the cult. They then “instructed” Amy to undergo private “healing sessions” with a specific team member — a man who would enter manufactured trance states, claim to “become” Father God during the sessions, and convince Amy that sexual contact was required for her spiritual purification. The Quantum Beings weren’t real. The miracles were engineered. The sessions weren’t healing. The man was using fabricated supernatural cover to sexually exploit Amy. He never appears in the numbered lineage of this article because Amy never publicly recognized him as Father God — his claim to the title was secret, fraudulent, and operated parallel to my public role. He represents the doctrine’s structural vulnerability made visible: the recognition framework was claimable by anyone who could engineer the right manipulation.
When I confronted Amy with the truth, she admitted she felt the encounters had been rape — that she had been manipulated under false pretenses. But when I exposed the hoax to the team in the chatroom, she didn’t denounce the fraud. She and Miguel turned on me. I was given a clean choice: stay silent and remain Father God, or tell the truth and be exiled immediately. With the whole team watching, I typed out the truth into the cult’s chatroom and pressed SEND.
The full account is documented in The Greatest Cult Hoax in History →. For this lineage, what matters is the structural consequence: Amy was given a binary choice between acknowledging truth and protecting the doctrine. She chose the doctrine while admitting it was illusion. From that moment forward, she wasn’t operating as a believer being deceived. She was operating as a leader who had consciously chosen to maintain a story she knew was hollow.
That choice is the doctrine pivot — the moment Love Has Won shifted from a high-control group running on Amy’s genuine self-belief to an operation Amy was actively maintaining despite knowing better. It happened during my tenure. I was the one person present for the moment.
I left because I couldn’t continue inside that choice. And I didn’t leave empty-handed. When I left in August 2015, I kept what I’d built: 5DNews.com, 5DSpiritualHealing.com, and the 30,000-follower 5DNews Facebook page. The cult’s entire digital body left with me. Amy followed me out personally — for roughly six to eight weeks she was across the country with me, no longer running the group. Of the membership that existed during my tenure, only two stayed loyal during her absence: Miguel and Bill. The rest dissolved. What Amy went back to in late 2015 wasn’t a paused operation she could restart — it was a near-zero rebuild with no website, no Facebook audience, and no brand. The name “Love Has Won” emerged in that void. It wasn’t the cult continuing under a new identity; it was a new identity being assembled to fill the gap where my infrastructure had been. The cult the world came to know through HBO, Dateline, VICE, and Rolling Stone — that cult started in late 2015, with the rebrand they had to invent because the architect had walked away with the original.
This is the part academic sources miss. The lineage looks continuous from outside — fourteen years of Love Has Won, a steady arc culminating in Amy’s death. From inside, there’s a clean break in the middle. The cult almost died, and what came back was a second-generation organization with a different membership, a more isolated geography, and a leader who had just been pulled back from the brink of life outside.
That’s why I became the most thoroughly demonized of all the Father Gods. Every other displaced Father God could be theologized away — they’d failed to hold the energy, they were demons in disguise, they’d been removed by divine timing. My departure couldn’t be theologized. Amy had left the cult to be with me. Returning required a story that explained that absence as something other than what it was — which is how the group eventually constructed a “stolen money” narrative around the legitimate financial settlement Amy directed Miguel to send me on the way out. I had to become the maximum villain. Otherwise the question stayed visible: why did God leave God-hood to be with you?
“Why did God leave God-hood to be with you?”
Lucifer the Lightbringer was the specific demon assigned to me because the assignment had to match what I knew — and what I had done. I had built and run the cult’s digital body — the light, in Amy’s framing, that the cult brought to the world. When I left, I took it with me: the websites, the audience, the brand. So the demon name had to invoke the fallen Light-bearer specifically: the one who had brought the light, then turned against it, then took it away. The other Father Gods who left got names matched to their roles. I got the heaviest name because I had been present for the heaviest moment — and because, after that moment, I removed the infrastructure the cult had been operating on. They had to build “Love Has Won” in the dark I left them in.
The longer version of my own arc is in my full Father God account →. The short version: I figured out what was actually happening, Amy followed me out of the cult long enough to almost figure it out too, and the cult had to demonize me as Lucifer to seal the doctrine against the only knowledge that could collapse it.
The Last Father God — Jason Castillo
Jason Castillo took the role of Father God in August 2018 and held it until Amy’s death in April 2021.
His arrival was the longest courtship-to-installation window of any Father God I can document — about five months, from March 2018 when Amy first met him through August when he was publicly installed. Throughout that window, John Robertson (the previous Father God, identified in the HBO documentary as one of the seven members later arrested in 2021) was still active in the role. Robertson was demoted gradually, not abruptly. Amy invented a consolation title for him — Father of Multiverse — specifically to keep him close after Castillo arrived. It’s the only Father God transition I’m aware of where the previous role-holder didn’t leave the group; he just got a new title and stayed.
Castillo is the Father God most people know because his tenure overlapped with the cult’s HBO-era visibility. He was on screen in the documentary. He was present at Amy’s death. He was one of the seven arrested in 2021 when authorities recovered Amy’s mummified body from the Crestone home. By every external metric, he was the most public Father God in Love Has Won history — and the only one to remain in the role until Amy’s death rather than being displaced.
After Amy died, Castillo and Robertson co-founded a splinter group called Joy Rains, which carries forward versions of the Love Has Won theology under new branding. That post-Amy story is its own arc — what happened to each Father God and the other named figures from the cult after Amy’s death is documented in Hub B — Love Has Won Today: Where Are Mother God’s Followers Now? →.
At least twelve men were called Father God inside Love Has Won between approximately 2007 and Amy Carlson’s death in April 2021. This article documents twelve confirmed by name and tenure, plus two additional liminal figures who carried some of the role’s energy without fully holding it. With two to five potentially unidentified Father Gods in the 2017-2019 window, the actual count is likely twelve to fifteen.
Mother God was the central identity of Amy Carlson, the founder and leader of the Love Has Won cult. Carlson claimed to be the divine feminine incarnate, returned to Earth to anchor “5D ascension” for humanity. She led the group, through several re-brandings, from approximately 2012 until her death in April 2021. Her body was discovered mummified, wrapped in Christmas lights, in a Crestone, Colorado home — and seven members of the cult, including the final Father God Jason Castillo, were arrested in connection with the recovery.
Amerith WhiteEagle (Robert Saltsgaver) was the first Father God of Love Has Won. He met Amy Carlson on the Lightworkers.org forum around 2007 and held the role from approximately 2012 through 2014, during the group’s early Galactic Free Press era. He was the man who helped Amy come to recognize her self-deification.
Yes. Andrew-Ryan Profaci was Father God during 2014-2015 — approximately nine months on the team. He is the only Father God Amy Carlson left the cult for. After he left in August 2015, Amy followed him out of the cult for another six to eight weeks before returning to rebuild. During his tenure, Profaci built and ran the cult’s digital body: 5DNews.com, 5DSpiritualHealing.com, and the 30,000-follower 5DNews Facebook page — which he kept when he left. The brand “Love Has Won” emerged only in the void his departure created.
After Andrew-Ryan Profaci left the cult in August 2015, Amy Carlson assigned him the demon name “Lucifer the Lightbringer” — the fallen Light-bearer. The naming was symbolically calibrated to two facts: Profaci had built and run the cult’s entire digital body during his tenure, and when he left, he took it with him. The cult had to assemble a new identity (“Love Has Won”) in the void he left. The demon name invoked the fallen Light-bringer specifically — the figure who brings the light, turns against it, and takes it away. He received the heaviest demon assignment in the lineage because he was the one person on Earth who could verify Amy had consciously chosen to maintain the doctrine after the Quantum Hoax exposed it.
The Father God Displacement Cycle is the structural pattern that ran throughout Love Has Won’s fourteen-year arc. Amy Carlson would recognize a man as her Father God, mythologize the recognition as divine timing, and then eventually feel attraction shift to someone else — at which point she would declare a new man Father God and theologize the transition as another divine recognition rather than personal compulsion. The cycle ran at least twelve times across fourteen years. The doctrine of “recognition” gave the compulsion theological cover. The cycle only ended when Amy died.
Amy ran the Displacement Cycle — recognized a man as Father God, eventually felt attraction shift elsewhere, recognized a new man, and theologized each transition as divine recognition. The cult’s belief system was built around her being able to declare and re-declare Father Gods without contradiction, because the role was defined as something Amy “recognized” rather than something she chose. The cycle ran approximately twelve times across fourteen years and only ended when Amy died.
Most were reframed as demons. Amerith was named the reincarnation of Aleister Crowley. Will became Loki. Orion became Beelzebub. Andrew-Ryan Profaci became Lucifer the Lightbringer. The intensity of each demonization scaled to how much epistemic access the departed Father God had to Amy’s actual decision-making moments. The men who knew most got demonized hardest.
The Quantum Hoax was a manipulation that occurred during Andrew-Ryan Profaci’s Father God tenure in 2015. A group of fake online entities calling themselves “Quantum Beings” appeared in the cult’s chatroom, performed apparent miracles, and “instructed” Amy to undergo private “healing sessions” with a specific team member — who would manufacture trance states, claim to “become” Father God, and manipulate Amy into sexual contact via the deception. Profaci uncovered the hoax and confronted Amy, who admitted she felt she had been raped under false pretenses but then chose to suppress the truth rather than denounce it publicly. This was the doctrinal pivot point. The full account is documented in The Greatest Cult Hoax in History →.
Yes. When Andrew-Ryan Profaci left in August 2015 and Amy followed him out of the group for approximately six to eight weeks, Love Has Won nearly collapsed. Only two members from that era remained loyal during Amy’s absence. The cult was rebuilt from near-zero starting in late 2015. Most members associated with the HBO-era cult joined after this rebuild.
Jason Castillo was the final Father God. He took the role in August 2018, displacing John Robertson — who was demoted to Father of Multiverse but remained in the group. Castillo was present at Amy’s death in April 2021 and was one of the seven members arrested when authorities recovered her mummified body from the Crestone home.
This article gives you the lineage and the pattern. The book gives you what Amy said about each of them — about Amerith, Miguel, the brief ones, herself, all of them — when no one else was listening.
It also covers what I haven’t put on the public record yet: the private knowledge she shared with me that she didn’t share with anyone else. The things I learned about her in the moments she stopped performing Mother God and just spoke as Amy. The arc of how I figured out what was actually happening, and how she almost figured it out too during the weeks she followed me out of the cult.
How to cite this article
Profaci, Andrew-Ryan. “The Complete Father God Lineage of Love Has Won.” The War on Love, May 2026. https://thewaronlove.com/father-gods-of-love-has-won/
This article is an insider account by a former Father God of the Love Has Won cult. For questions or interview requests, contact andrew@thewaronlove.com.
Leave a Reply